Review of Shakespeare's Cousin at the White Bear Theatre


★★★
Jonathan Moore's Shakespeare's Cousin is an intriguing and often intelligent piece of theatre, built around a fascinating historical premise: the imagined meeting between William Shakespeare and his distant cousin, the Jesuit priest and poet Robert Southwell, imprisoned during the reign of Elizabeth I.
The first half is particularly effective. The exchanges between Southwell and Sir Richard Topcliffe, the notorious priest-hunter responsible for his interrogation, are absorbing, with Moore's writing displaying a cleverness and command of language that I found genuinely enjoyable. There is an interesting battle of wits between the two men, with Topcliffe's outward civility concealing a much more sinister character. One could almost be lulled into believing this is an innocent conversation, were it not for the occasional hints of Topcliffe's sadistic nature. Indeed, Topcliffe goes on to describe in some detail the torture he intends to inflict on Southwell. While some detail is understandable in establishing the brutality of his methods, the lengthy verbal description is more than sufficient. The accompanying drawings depicting the torture are entirely unnecessary and, given the level of detail already provided, feel almost patronising, as though the audience needs the brutality spelt out visually as well. The tension continues to build nicely until Southwell is sent down to the dungeon at Topcliffe's house. His apparent lack of protest at being led away, however, is an odd and rather unconvincing moment.
Unfortunately, the play begins to lose its way in the second half. Shakespeare arrives at Southwell's cell in the Tower disguised as Sir Oliver, a Protestant visitor ostensibly there to persuade the imprisoned priest to recant his faith. Topcliffe appears to believe this is the visitor's purpose and has agreed to allow him some privacy with Southwell. The disguise is eventually dropped and the two cousins embark on an increasingly lengthy and often light-hearted discussion about religion, poetry and matters of conscience.
The problem is that Shakespeare seems remarkably trusting of Topcliffe, given his calculating and duplicitous nature. To believe that their conversation would remain private simply because Topcliffe had agreed to it is difficult to accept. Surely Shakespeare would have realised that Topcliffe might well have someone listening in. The occasional attempts to slip back into the character of Sir Oliver, presumably to convince any eavesdropping guards that the visitor is still playing his original role, simply don't work. The familiarity, volume and often jovial nature of their exchanges make the pretence thoroughly unconvincing.
There is a further, lengthy explanation of torture and the manner of death towards the end of the second half. This adds little to what we have already been told and feels particularly unnecessary. Worse still, it comes after the audience had clearly been led to believe the play had ended. Having thought the evening was over, enduring a further fifteen minutes felt somewhat torturous in itself.
The acting, however, is exceptional. Robin Kingsland is outstanding as Topcliffe, delivering a wonderfully controlled portrayal that moves effortlessly between charm and menace. Danny Solomon is equally impressive as Southwell, while Alex Townson's Shakespeare, although perfectly competent, doesn't quite match the strength of the other two performances.
Shakespeare's Cousin starts with considerable promise and has much to admire in its writing and performances. Sadly, the implausibility of the Tower encounter and an overlong, unnecessarily extended conclusion prevent it from fulfilling its potential. A good play that could have been considerably better with some judicious editing.
Run ends: 28 November 2026
Venue: White Bear 138 Kennington Park Rd, London SE11 4DJ
Tickets: £23.00 (£18.00 concs)
Performance times: Tuesday–Saturday | 7.30pm
Running time: 2 hours including the interval










Comments